X
GO

Spiritual Care - Synthesis

Introduction

Spirituality contributes to quality of life and wellbeing. [1] It has been associated with positive emotional and mental health [2,3] and the ability to cope in a time of stress. [2] For many people, spirituality is important throughout life; for many older people, the identification and support of spiritual needs is especially important at the end of life. [4,5] Definitions of spirituality are debated in the literature and often described as making connections, searching for or giving meaning and purpose to life, and seeking transcendence. [1-9] Spirituality can occur in the absence of any religious affiliation or practice. [1-4,7-10]
 

Quality Statement

The quality of the included literature is of acceptable to high quality. 

The National Guidelines for Spiritual Care in Aged Care [1] and the associated literature review [4] were retrieved. They specifically pertain to spirituality in older adults. Systematic reviews were found pertaining to the combined palliative care context and aged care context [3,10], palliative care context alone [5,8,9,11-13] or aged care context alone. [2,6] A report was also retrieved which records consensus via two conferences (2012 and 2013); this pertains to spirituality broadly and is not specific to either the palliative care or aged care context. [7] A recently published qualitative primary study was included as it identifies organisational-level principles and practices that support high-quality spiritual care at end-of-life. [14]
 

Evidence Synthesis

The experience of ill-health particularly at end-of-life can rekindle or intensify spiritual or religious awareness and early research suggests positive associations with spirituality, positive emotion and mental health. [2-5] At the end of life, spiritual or religious belief may help the person’s coping and facilitate a renewed peace of mind in approaching death, finding meaning and purpose in their final days. [3]

The recognition that health professionals have a role in spiritual or religious care is relatively recent. [1,3,4,7,12] The authors of the National Guidelines for Spiritual Care in Aged Care suggest that spiritual care is best delivered through a whole-of-organisation approach. [1,4,6] The authors also highlight the importance of a spiritual assessment for all people receiving aged care: an initial spiritual screening and an in-depth spiritual assessment. [1]
 

Measurement of spirituality – tools and instruments

The measurement of spirituality is essential in screening and assessment. [5,8,9,15]

The ConnecTo Tool is available to assess spirituality in older adults. [15] Recent research recommends that shorter scales be developed to maximise respect of patient quality of life and that technological aids and devices be used to enhance information collection and use. [13]

Gijsbert et al. [5] use the instruments measuring spirituality in end-of-life populations to develop a model conceptualising spirituality. This model has three dimensions 1) Spiritual Wellbeing, 2) Spiritual Cognitive Behavioural Context (including spiritual beliefs, spiritual activities, and spiritual relationships), and 3) Spiritual Coping. All three dimensions and sub-dimensions inter-relate. The authors consider spiritual wellbeing as a care outcome, to which all others can contribute. 

Two reviews by Selman et al. [8,9] investigate the culturally diverse aspects of spirituality and focus on multicultural advanced cancer, HIV, and palliative care populations. The first review [8] identifies and categorises spiritual outcome measures, and assesses the cross-cultural applicability of tools used to assess spirituality. They find that of the 38 tools validated in these populations, only nine had been validated in either one or more ethnically diverse population or in more than one country. The second review [9] builds on this review and appraises the psychometric properties, multifaith appropriateness, and completion time of spiritual outcome measures of these nine tools. The authors conclude that the McGill Quality of Life Questionnaire (MQOL), the Measuring the Quality of Life of Seriously Ill Patients Questionnaire(QUAL-E), and the Palliative Outcome Scale (POS) seem the most appropriate multidimensional measures containing spiritual items for use in these populations as they have the strong psychometric properties. Selman et al. indicate that the World Health Organization’s Quality of Life Instrument-HIV (WHOQOL-HIV) has promising psychometric properties and recommend acquiring further evidence of reliability and responsiveness. They also indicate that although the Beck Hopelessness Scale (BHS) has the strongest psychometric properties, further testing of reliability specifically in palliative care populations is needed.

A review by Oliver et al. [13] on spiritual tools for palliative care summarises 14 papers published during 2014–2015. The authors recommend that to better respect patient quality of life, shorter scales and measurement protocols should be developed. They also recommend that spirituality evaluation tools include new issues such as complicated grief or satisfaction with spiritual care, and that these should take a combined perspective: the person, their family and healthcare professionals.
 

Spiritual care or spiritual interventions

Spiritual care is an important aspect of palliative care, holistic or inclusive care, dignity-conserving care, respectful and culturally-appropriate care, and compassionate care. [1,4,7,12] Spiritual care includes sensitive and respectful interactions, empathetic communication, activities like story-telling, reminiscing, mindfulness and meditation, prayer, [6] therapeutic life review [10] or dignity therapy. [12]

Jackson et al. [6] found many definitions of spiritual care and spirituality in the literature, but none specifically for aged care. They found spiritual care can be provided well by team members with varying backgrounds and that the entire aged care team had a role in the spiritual care of older adults. They suggest that a whole-of-organisation approach may better support and maintain good practice rather than expecting individual staff to accept responsibility for incorporating spiritual care. The above findings lead to the development The National Guidelines for Spiritual Care in Aged Care. [1] They describe the elements of spiritual care in aged care as assessment, trusting relationships, compassion, reminiscence and story-telling, mindfulness and meditation, as well as explicit religious practices such as ritual, prayer and reading scripture. 

Candy et al. [3] in a Cochrane review of quantitative studies, describe spiritual and religious interventions for adults in the terminal phase of a disease and their effectiveness on wellbeing. Only five studies met the inclusion criteria. Two studies evaluated meditation. Three studies evaluated the work of a palliative care team that involved physicians, nurses and chaplains. Studies compared those who received the intervention with a control group. Studies evaluated the interventions in various ways including whether it influenced a person’s quality of life. The results were inconclusive as to the benefits of meditation. The results also failed to show whether palliative care teams that involve a chaplain or spiritual counsellor help patients feel emotionally supported. The paucity of quality research indicates the need for more rigorous studies.

Therapeutic life review has been shown to be beneficial for older people through the recognition of accomplishments and resolution of conflicts. It can be seen as more powerful than reminiscence; the search for meaning in life events can be beneficial in bringing peace. Keall et al. [10] explored the role of therapeutic life review in the existential and spiritual domains of palliative care. The authors note the paucity of research in this area. They conclude that the diversity of interventions and measures used in any research, make it difficult to determine the most effective way to conduct therapeutic life review with people receiving palliative care. As these people are already very ill, the authors note, not unexpectedly, that shorter interventions are more beneficial. The authors caution that adequate staff training is important for the successful delivery of this intervention as deep psychosocial issues may be aroused, indicating the need for subsequent psychosocial support. 

Psychosocial issues such as settling relationships, expressing feelings of love, and preparing legacies of memory and shared values, take on a heightened importance at the end of life. Dignity Therapy (DT) focuses on issues such as these.  In exploring DT, Fitchett at al. [12] found robust evidence for DT’s overwhelming acceptability. The authors suggest that its mechanisms may be related to role completion and spiritual aspects of a person’s life. They recommend further research to accurately determine the possibility that its main impact is in a spiritual dimension. They also see the potential positive value that DT may have for the family and carers of people with a life-limiting chronic disease.
 

Organisation-level principles and practices to support spiritual care at the end of life

Despite the recognised importance of spiritual care in quality end-of-life care, Holyoke and Stephenson [14] note the historical progressive distancing and separation between modern medicine and religious and spiritual attitudes, ideas, and practices. From their investigation of practices in established palliative care organisations founded and operated on specific spiritual foundations, they developed nine principles for organisational support for spiritual care. Three principles identify where and how spiritual care fits with the other aspects of palliative care; three principles guide the organisational approach to spiritual care; and three principles support the spiritual practice of care providers within the organisations. This research recognises the vocational nature of palliative care, suggesting that with organisational support, it is possible for spirituality to become a defining feature of the nature and quality of end-of-life care. They recommend that spiritual care be guided and directed by the dying person and his/her family; this can be achieved when an organisation enables care providers to have a flexible, adaptive, immediate, in-the-moment approach to responding to spiritual needs and a conducive physical environment. They recognise the significance of rituals (not necessarily religious), time for processing experiences, strong staff interpersonal bonds, and the presence of volunteers.
 

Spirituality in aged care

The first National Guidelines for Spiritual Care in Aged Care [1] were published in Australia in 2016. The Guidelines provide a framework for best practice in spiritual care for older people and are accompanied by resources, suggestions and ideas for implementation. [16] These Guidelines are designed specifically for offering spiritual care and support to older people living in residential aged care, or receiving care and support through home care packages. Recommended is a whole-of-organisation approach and included is a section to address the spiritual wellbeing of certain groups of older people with special needs.
 

Spirituality and older adults with dementia

Spirituality and religion appear to have positive effects on older adults with dementia. [2,6] 
Agli et al. [2] investigated the effects of spirituality and religion on health outcomes and note that the positive effects of spirituality and religion are observed in the majority of included studies. These practices allow cognitive functions to improve, or at least stabilise, and also enrich coping strategies enabling a better quality of life. These results confirm findings from previous studies. The authors suggest that this may be through the maintenance of social interactions, the search for meaning in life, and that prayer may give beneficial stimulation to neural pathways. The authors caution that certain weaknesses across studies have been identified, which could be addressed in future research to increase methodological rigor and a stronger evidence base.

Jackson et al. [6] acknowledge the importance of rituals in providing cues, patterns and symbols to older people living with cognitive impairment or with dementia. These rituals may include familiar sights, or spaces, or the familiar order of prayer or reading of scripture. It appears that these rituals are helpful in immersing people in the deeper meaning of their faith and spirituality, and thus provide comfort. These authors also note that access to scriptures can assist in managing anxiety, depression, stressful situations, and contribute to spiritual care of older adults. Prayer was also seen to offer a sense of strength and comfort for older people living with dementia particularly if it was offered in a personal and meaningful way.
 

Deathbed phenomena as a trigger for spiritual discussions

Deathbed phenomena (DBP) is also known as ‘Transcendence Phenomena’ [17] DBP is characterised by visions and is an unusual and hard-to-explain end-of-life experience.  Although it is not uncommon in the health care setting, DBP may not always be reported by patients or their carers. In a review, Devery et al. [11] acknowledge that DBP may be a new and intense spiritual experience or it may be an extension of spiritual beliefs and lifelong bonds and relationships. These experiences may be very disconcerting for the person and their family and carers; consequently, they may find it difficult to understand and to share with others.  If these phenomena are shared, health professionals may use this as an opportunity to discuss spiritual and existential concerns, which have the potential to offer hope, meaning and connection. [11]  In doing so, it is important to ask the person to describe the experience and what it means to them, and to listen without labelling or judging. It is also important to reassure them that this is a common experience. 
 

Evidence Gaps

  • Research with larger sample sizes and methodological rigour is needed to build the existing evidence base for spirituality and spiritual care for older people in a palliative care context. It relationship to complicated grief could be explored.
  • More qualitative research is needed to determine for whom, by whom, how, when and under what conditions spiritual care is most beneficial.
  • Spiritual support for carers and family of older people at end-of-life is rarely researched. There is some evidence to suggest that carers may indirectly benefit from interventions, but there is also a need for interventions designed specifically for carers; and to understand if and how it may help in the period of bereavement.
  • There is promising evidence in the role of meaningful activities and spirituality/religion in the health and wellbeing of people with dementia. Future research with more methodological rigour could validate findings from current studies.
  • There is a lack of consistency in the way existential suffering is defined and the way it may be understood to be a spiritual concern. Ways to address existential suffering and deep personal anguish at the end-of-life are not well understood.
  • Future research could track the implementation the nine organisation-level principles and practices to support spiritual care at the end of life proposed by Holyoke and Stephenson [14] including a description of the lessons learned.

Page created 12 October 2017
  • References

  1. Meaningful Ageing Australia. National Guidelines for Spiritual Care in Aged Care [Internet]. 2016 Aug [cited 2017 Oct 11].
  2. Agli O, Bailly N, Ferrand C. Spirituality and religion in older adults with dementia: a systematic review. Int Psychogeriatr. 2015 May;27(5):715-25. doi: 10.1017/S1041610214001665. Epub 2014 Aug 26.
  3. Candy B, Jones L, Varagunam M, Speck P, Tookman A, King M. Spiritual and religious interventions for well-being of adults in the terminal phase of disease. Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2012 May 16;(5):CD007544. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD007544.pub2.
  4. Doyle C, Capon H. National Guidelines for Spiritual Care in Aged Care; Background and Literature Review (1.18MB pdf). Parkville (VIC): Meaningful Ageing Australia; 2016.
  5. Gijsberts MJ, Echteld MA, van der Steen JT, Muller MT, Otten RH, Ribbe MW, et al. Spirituality at the end of life: conceptualization of measurable aspects-a systematic review. J Palliat Med. 2011 Jul;14(7):852-63. doi: 10.1089/jpm.2010.0356. Epub 2011 May 25.
  6. Jackson D, Doyle C, Capon H, Pringle E. Spirituality, spiritual need, and spiritual care in aged care: What the literature says. J Relig Spiritual Aging. 2016;28(4):281-95.
  7. Puchalski CM, Vitillo R, Hull SK, Reller N. Improving the spiritual dimension of whole person care: reaching national and international consensus. J Palliat Med. 2014 Jun;17(6):642-56. doi: 10.1089/jpm.2014.9427. Epub 2014 May 19.
  8. Selman L, Harding R, Gysels M, Speck P, Higginson IJ. The measurement of spirituality in palliative care and the content of tools validated cross-culturally: a systematic review. J Pain Symptom Manage. 2011 Apr;41(4):728-53.
  9. Selman L, Siegert R, Harding R, Gysels M, Speck P, Higginson IJ. A psychometric evaluation of measures of spirituality validated in culturally diverse palliative care populations. J Pain Symptom Manage. 2011 Oct;42(4):604-22.
  10. Keall RM, Clayton JM, Butow PN. Therapeutic life review in palliative care: a systematic review of quantitative evaluations. J Pain Symptom Manage. 2015 Apr;49(4):747-61.
  11. Devery K, Rawlings D, Tieman J, Damarell R. Deathbed phenomena reported by patients in palliative care: clinical opportunities and responses. Int J Palliat Nurs. 2015 Mar;21(3):117-25.
  12. Fitchett G, Emanuel L, Handzo G, Boyken L, Wilkie DJ. Care of the human spirit and the role of dignity therapy: a systematic review of dignity therapy research. BMC Palliat Care. 2015 Mar 21;14:8. doi: 10.1186/s12904-015-0007-1. eCollection 2015.
  13. Oliver A, Galiana L, Benito E. Evaluation tools for spiritual support in end of life care: increasing evidence for their clinical application. Curr Opin Support Palliat Care. 2015 Dec;9(4):357-60. doi: 10.1097/SPC.0000000000000173.
  14. Holyoke P, Stephenson B. Organization-level principles and practices to support spiritual care at the end of life: a qualitative study. BMC Palliat Care. 2017 Apr 11;16(1):24. doi: 10.1186/s12904-017-0197-9.
  15. Meaningful Ageing Australia. ConnecTo. 2017 [cited 2017 Oct 12].
  16. Maeaningful Ageing Australia. National Guidelines Implementation Tools. 2016 [cited 2017 Oct 12].
  17. Broadhurst K, Harrington A. A Thematic Literature Review: The Importance of Providing Spiritual Care for End-of-Life Patients Who Have Experienced Transcendence Phenomena. Am J Hosp Palliat Care. 2016 Nov;33(9):881-93. Epub 2015 Jul 12.